Loading Carshug
VS

Mg Comet Ev

₹7.50 Lakh onwards
Electric Automatic N/A
MG Comet EV Executive
MG Comet EV Executive
MG Comet EV Excite
MG Comet EV Excite Fc
MG Comet EV Exclusive
MG Comet EV Exclusive Fc 100 Year Edition
MG Comet EV Exclusive Fc
MG Comet EV Blackstorm Edition

Tata Punch Ev

₹6.49 Lakh onwards
Electric Automatic N/A
Tata Punch EV Smart 30kwh With Baas
Tata Punch EV Smart 30kwh With Baas
Tata Punch EV Smart 30kwh
Tata Punch EV Smart+ 30kwh
Tata Punch EV Smart+ 40kwh
Tata Punch EV Adventure 40kwh
Tata Punch EV Empowered 40kwh
Tata Punch EV Empowered+ S 40kwh
Do you want to find out which car is the better choice, Mg Comet Ev or Tata Punch Ev? The Mg Comet Ev is priced from ₹7.50 Lakh, whereas the Tata Punch Ev starts at ₹6.49 Lakh (ex-showroom). In terms of core specifications, the Mg Comet Ev is an electric vehicle equipped with a 17.4 kWh battery pack available with Automatic transmissions. Comparatively, the Tata Punch Ev features an electric powertrain with a 40 kWh battery paired with Automatic transmissions. When it comes to efficiency, the Mg Comet Ev offers an estimated driving range of up to 230 km km/charge, while the Tata Punch Ev provides a range of up to 464 km km/charge depending on driving conditions.
Read More

Mg Comet Ev vs Tata Punch Ev

Do you want to find out which car is the better choice, Mg Comet Ev or Tata Punch Ev? The Mg Comet Ev is priced from ₹7.50 Lakh, whereas the Tata Punch Ev starts at ₹6.49 Lakh (ex-showroom). In terms of core specifications, the Mg Comet Ev is an electric vehicle equipped with a 17.4 kWh battery pack available with Automatic transmissions. Comparatively, the Tata Punch Ev features an electric powertrain with a 40 kWh battery paired with Automatic transmissions. When it comes to efficiency, the Mg Comet Ev offers an estimated driving range of up to 230 km km/charge, while the Tata Punch Ev provides a range of up to 464 km km/charge depending on driving conditions.

Key Highlights Mg Comet Ev Tata Punch Ev
Price ₹7.50 Lakh* ₹6.49 Lakh*
Engine / Battery 17.4 kWh 40 kWh
Power - -
Mileage / Range 230 km km/charge 464 km km/charge
  • Engine & Transmission
  • Dimensions & Capacity
  • Brakes, Suspension & Tyres
  • Safety
  • Exterior
  • Comfort & Convenience
  • Instrumentation
  • Infotainment & Communication
  • Warranty
  • Top Key Features
  • Pros & Cons
Mg Comet Ev
Mg Comet Ev ₹7.50 Lakh • Electric
VS
Tata Punch Ev ₹6.49 Lakh • Electric
Tata Punch Ev
Hide Similar Specs

Engine & Transmission

No
Acceleration
13.5 secs (0-100 kmph)
17.3
Battery Capacity
30
Lithium ion
Battery Type
Lithium ion
7 Hours
Charging Time
26 mins (20-80%) with 65 kW DC Fast Charger
RWD
Drivetrain
FWD
No
Emission Norm
Zero Tailpipe emission
No
Fast Charging
Yes
Electric
Fuel Type
Electric
30891 W
Motor Power
65000 W
230
Range
375
100
Top Speed
No
110Nm
Torque
154 Nm
Automatic
Transmission Type
Automatic
No
Turbocharger
No

Dimensions & Capacity

hatchback
Body Type
SUV
350
Boot Space
366
165
Ground Clearance
190
1640
Height
1622
817
Kerb Weight
1360
2974
Length
3880
3
No. of Doors
4
4
No. of Seats
5
2010
Wheelbase
2445
1505
Width
1742

Brakes, Suspension & Tyres

Disc
Front Brakes
Disc
McPherson Strut
Front Suspension
Independent& Lower Wishbone& McPherson Strut with Coil Spring
145/70 R12
Front Tyre Size
185/70 R15
Drum
Rear Brakes
Drum
Multi-Link Coil Suspension
Rear Suspension
Semi-independent Twist Beam With Coil Spring And Shock Absorber
145/70 R12
Rear Tyre Size
185/70 R15
No
Spare Wheel
No
4.2
Turning Radius
No
R12
Wheels Size
R15
Steel Rim With Wheel Covers
Wheels Type
Steel Wheels

Safety

Yes
ABS (Anti-lock Braking System)
Yes
No
ADAS
No
No
ASR / Traction Control
No
2 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger)
Airbag Details
6 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger, 2 Curtain, Driver Side, Front Passenger Side)
2
Airbags
6
Not Tested
BNCAP Adult Rating
5 Star
Not Tested
BNCAP Child Rating
5 Star
Not Tested
BNCAP Rating
5 Star
No
Blind Spot Detection
No
No
Blind Spot Monitor
No
Yes
Central Locking
No
Yes
Child Safety Lock
Yes
No
Dashcam
No
No
Door Ajar Warning
Yes
No
EBA (Electronic Brake Assist)
No
Yes
EBD (Electronic Brake-force Distribution)
Yes
No
ESP (Electronic Stability Program)
Yes
No
Emergency Brake Light Flashing
No
Yes
Fog Lights
No
Not Tested
GNCAP Adult Rating
Not Tested
Not Tested
GNCAP Child Rating
Not Tested
Not Tested
GNCAP Rating
Not Tested
No
Hill Assist
Yes
No
Hill Descent Control
No
Yes
ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount)
Yes
Manually Adjustable
Inside Rear View Mirror
Manually Adjustable
No
Lane Departure Warning
No
No
Lane Watch Camera/ Side Mirror Camera
No
1 beep over 80kmph & Continuous beeps over 120kmph
Overspeed Warning
No
No
Parking Camera
No
No
Rear Middle Head Rest
No
Yes
Rear Middle Three Point seatbelt
Yes
Yes
Seat Belt Warning
Yes
Yes
Speed Sensing Door Lock
Yes
No
Surround View Camera
No
Yes
Tyre Pressure Monitoring System
Yes

Exterior

No
Antenna
No
No
Automatic Headlamps
No
Manual Lift
Bonnet
Manual Lift
Body Coloured
Bumpers
Black
No
Daytime Running Lights
Yes
Yes
Follow Me Home Headlamps
No
Electrically Adjustable
Outside Mirrors
Manually Adjustable
Body Coloured With Indicators
Outside Rear View Mirrors
Black With Indicators
Chrome
Outside door handles
Body Coloured
Front Only
Power Windows
Front Only
Yes
Rear Defogger
No
Body Coloured Roof Mounted
Rear Spoiler
Black Boot Mounted
No
Rear Wiper
No
No
Roof Rails
No
No
Sunroof
No
Manually Operation
Tail Gate
Powered

Comfort & Convenience

Yes
AC
Yes
No
Adjustable Headrests
Yes
No
Adjustable Steering
Tilt Only
No
Ambient Light
No
No
Auto Park
No
No
Automatic climate control
Yes
No
Boss Mode
No
Front Only
Cabin Lights
Front Only
12V & Usb
Charging Outlets - Front Row
12V Only
No
Charging Outlets - Second Row
No
Manual Adjust - Slide& Recline
Co-Driver Seat Adjustment
Manual Adjust - Slide And Recline
No
Cruise Control
No
No
Cup Holders
Yes
Yes
Distance to Empty display
No
3
Drive Modes
2
Manual Adjust - Slide& Recline
Driver Seat Adjustment
Manual Adjust - Slide& Recline And Height
No
Electronically Adjustable Seats
No
Yes
Folding Rear Seat
Yes
No
Front Armrest
No
Driver & Co-Driver Side
Front Seat Back Pockets
Driver & Co-Driver Side
Yes
GPS & Navigation
No
No
Glove Box Cooling
No
No
Glovebox Lamp
No
No
Head Up Display
No
Led
Headlamps
Halogen
Yes
Headlight Height Adjuster
No
No
Headlight and Ignition On Reminder
No
Yes
Heater
Yes
{7 inches}, Digital Console
Instrument Console
4 inches& Digital Console
Foldable Key
Keyless Entry
No
No
Leather streering wheels
No
No
Massage Seats
No
Yes
Multifunction Steering Wheel
No
Yes
Paddle Shifters
No
No
Parcel Tray
Yes
Yes
Parking Assist
No
Manual Hand Brake
Parking Brake
Manual Hand brake
Rear Only
Parking Sensors
Rear Only
Yes
Power Steering
Yes
No
Rear AC Vents
No
No
Rear Armrest
No
No
Rear Row Seat Adjustment
No
Yes
Reclining Rear Seats
No
No
Seat Back Table
No
Fabric
Seat Upholstery
Fabric
Yes
Split Rear Seat
No
No
Start / Stop Button
No
No
Sunshades
No
No
Vanity Mirrors on Sun Visors
No
No
Ventilated Seats
No
No
Ventilated Seats Type
No
No
puddle lamp
No

Instrumentation

Yes
Adjustable Cluster Brightness
Yes
No
Avg fuel economy display
No
Digital
Fuel level guage
Digital
No
Low Fuel Level Warning
No
Digital
Odometer
Digital
No
Shift Indicator
No
Digital
Speedometer
Digital
Digital
Tachometer
Digital

Infotainment & Communication

Yes
AM/FM Radio
No
No
Android Auto and Apple Carplay
No
Yes
Bluetooth Compatibility
No
Yes
Front tweeters
No
No
Gesture Control
No
Yes
Infotainment Screen
No
Standard Company Fitted
Integrated Music System
No
Yes
Multifunction Display
No
2
Speakers
No
10.25 inches
Touchscreen Size
No
No
Voice Command
No
No
Wireless Charger
No

Warranty

Vehicle Warranty - 3 Years/100000 kms& Battery Warranty - 8 Years/120000 Kms
Basic Warranty
Vehicle - 3 Years/125000 kms& Motor - 8 Years/160000 kms& Battery - 8 Years/160000 kms
Upto 5 Years/220000 Kms
Extended Warranty
No

Top Key Features

Multifunction Steering Wheel
Drive Modes
GPS & Navigation
ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount)
Follow Me Home Headlamps
Automatic climate control
Drive Modes
ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount)
Hill Assist
Daytime Running Lights

Pros & Cons

PROS
The gigantic, high-definition display perfectly integrates your smartphone, making navigation incredibly immersive.
The electric powertrain delivers incredibly smooth, linear acceleration in utter, serene silence.
The bold, imposing front grille guarantees the COMET-EV commands massive respect and presence on the road.
Superior cabin insulation effectively blocks out annoying traffic noise, creating a whisper-quiet passenger experience.
The suspension is incredibly soft, specifically tuned to swallow deep potholes and isolate passengers from harsh roads.
The plush leatherette seating offers exceptional under-thigh support, completely eliminating fatigue on long inter-state journeys. [Config: COMET-EV Executive]
The automatic gearbox transforms this PUNCH into an effortless daily city commuter.
Cabin insulation in the Smart 30kWh With BaaS effectively blocks out annoying traffic noise.
The steering of the PUNCH is light at low speeds, making city parking effortless.
The braking hardware on the PUNCH provides reassuring bite during emergency stops.
The suspension of the PUNCH is perfectly tuned to absorb unpredictable city potholes.
Wide-opening doors make entering and exiting the Smart 30kWh With BaaS extremely easy.
CONS
Missing a parking camera on a vehicle with such massive blind spots feels like severe budget-cutting by MG.
Standard steel wheels look incredibly cheap and completely ruin the otherwise premium aesthetic of the COMET-EV.
Missing a sunroof is a massive letdown for buyers expecting the full luxury MG experience.
The glaring absence of ADAS puts the total burden of safety squarely on the driver.
It feels noticeably overpriced for what you get, especially when you calculate the on-road budget.
MG's massive infotainment screen can occasionally suffer from frustrating software lag and painfully slow boot-up times.
The lack of a factory parking camera makes reversing the PUNCH-EV Smart 30kWh With BaaS unnecessarily stressful.
Standard steel wheels make the PUNCH-EV look basic at this tier.
Missing a modern touchscreen leaves the dashboard of the Smart 30kWh With BaaS looking dated.
The solid roof makes the Smart 30kWh With BaaS's cabin feel slightly more enclosed.
Missing advanced driver assists puts the total burden of safety entirely on the driver.
Piano black interior trims in the Smart 30kWh With BaaS act as a magnet for dust and scratches.

Unlock Exclusive Dealer Offers

Enter your details below to get instant quotes and current month discounts from verified local dealers.